I don't think so,I cannot believe MP's debated this for how long without even trying to tackle the bigger picture.
The following article just appeared on a news site and I figured this must be happening the length and breadth of the country.
i hate to think how night clubs are dealing with this-if you have any examples please email me.
The thought of 20-30 drunk lads all popping out for a fag at 1am scares the shit out of me.
‘This smoking ban is giving me a headache’
Marc Mullen
ALL the best laid plans of Camden Council's licensing committee have gone up in smoke for one Hampstead pub since July 1.
Ye Olde White Bear in New End was given permission last year to serve booze until 11.30pm, provided customers were not using the tables at the front of the pub past 11pm.
Chris Ely, owner of Ye Olde White Bear, said this worked perfectly well until the smoking ban came into effect on July 1.
Now customers nipping out for a crafty fag after 11pm are being told they must have their nicotine fix away from the pub.
Mr Ely said: "At 11pm customers came inside but we were still open and there was never any confrontation.
"But now since the smoking ban came into force it has been an absolute nightmare.
"If a customer nips outside for a fag after 11pm, they cannot use our tables as we are not licensed. They must smoke off the premises, which means they have to cross a golden studded line, which divides the pavement in half.
"How can we police that? It worked well, but now it is just stupid. People don't understand and I find myself having to explain the inexplicable."
The issue has led to fears that more pubs which have licences preventing late night drinking outside will face the same dilemma.
In South End Green, the Garden Gate and the Roebuck both have 11pm curfews on outdoor drinking.
Pam Gilby, chairwoman of the South End Green Association, said: "It certainly does raise an issue with the licensing provision. I think the answer would have to be they can be outside for a cigarette, but just not drinking.
"There are people who oppose all licensing changes and I am sure they would oppose that."
When the Royal Free Hospital banned smoking within its grounds last year there were complaints when patients, some in wheelchairs and pyjamas, were seen smoking on Pond Street.
In Holly Bush Vale, the Holly Bush pub had a long-running problem with noisy customers, which it resolved after working with its neighbours.
Holly Bush owner Nicholai Outzen said: "I don't think the buildings around the White Bear amplify the noise of people talking like they do here.
"It's a bummer, but the best thing he could do is move the tables up against the wall at 11pm, so that people cannot use them.
"Before he did control his customers, but now he has to send them across the road, nearer to neighbours who may have complained in the first place and where he cannot control them.
"If his neighbours have a go at him for that, that is not fair."
http://www.hamhigh.co.uk
And heres another article from a similar perspective.
Smoking ban comes under fire
It may have been in place for less than a month, but the smoking ban is already coming under fire – this time from a non-smoker.
Karen Hill, of New Street, St Neots, was looking forward to the new smoking ban.
However, since July 1 Karen and her husband Daniel have been overwhelmed by smokers standing outside their home.
She claims some have thrown cigarette butts into their garden and the smell of smoke regularly enters the home they have lived in for two years.
However, Karen, 27, says it's not just a problem local to her and regularly sees groups of smokers hanging around outside pubs and restaurants.
She said: "It's an invasion of privacy and there is smoke coming into our house, which isn't very pleasant. I am entitled to breathe smoke-free air.
"I feel let down that nobody thought through where these smokers were going to go, they just chucked them out onto the street.
"It's just moving the problem from one place to another and therefore causing different problems.
"It is also down to the smokers to be considerate, rather than just down to the pubs themselves."
Huntingdonshire District Council's smokefree implementation officer Oliver Langford said: "As a result of the law, people may ultimately gather outside to smoke, so we are encouraging pubs and restaurants to take into consideration nearby residents and noise levels.
"It is very important that everyone is aware of their responsibilities and I am more than happy to assist with any queries that arise while on visits."
Is any of this a surprise? Have we all not had these conversations for months now-I know of one example where a guy inhis 50's who wouldn't say boo to anyone,went to his town local on the first night of the ban,popped outside with his pint for a fag and got a £50 fine for drinking in the street-ok he should have known the law,but he didn't,had never concerned him before-no softly softly for him.
Labels: camden, hamstead, huntingdon, st neots